Adam J. Powell's work utilizes a robust theoretical framework to present the connection between the opposition faced by religious communities and the development of new doctrines, specifically deification.... This text offers an important contribution to the discussion of Mormon history and how doctrines form in light of exterior forces. This text is well researched and offers an important theoretical framework for the study of heresy's impact on religious movements.

Journal of Mormon History

In just over two hundred pages, Powell manages to produce not only a fascinating comparison between Joseph Smith’s nineteenth-century Mormonism and the religious thought of second-century church father Irenaeus, but also introduces an innovative application of the work of Max Weber and Hans Mol to the question of religious conflict management.... [B]ooks like Powell’s are important, pioneering steps toward a more mature notion of how Mormonism can function as a suitable subject of study for scholars interested in the nature of religion as a concept and as a fully integrated cultural agent.

Mormon Studies Review

At first glance, second-century bishop Irenaeus of Lyon and Joseph Smith . . . don't seem to have much in common. . . .However, as Dr. Adam Powell shows in his fascinating study, Irenaeus, Joseph Smith God-Making Heresy, they and their communities shared a great deal.

New Books Network

Powell does an admirable job of articulating many striking similarities surrounding the formation of early Christianity, as represented by Irenaeus, and the formation of early Mormonism. Those similarities are compelling, and well-worth examining. . . .Sociologists of religion will find this book of value.

AML's Dawning of a Brighter Day

Irenaeus, Joseph Smith, and God-Making Heresy is very highly recommended for academic library Christian Studies collections.

Midwest Book Review