Minority Report

Dissent and Diversity in Science

Minority Report

Dissent and Diversity in Science

William T. Lynch (Author)

Online resources available

Hardback ~~$220.00~~ $198.00 Ebook (Epub & Mobi) ~~$198.00~~ $158.40 Ebook (PDF) ~~$198.00~~ $158.40

Quantity

In stock

$198.00 RRP $220.00 Website price saving $22.00 (10%)

Add to basket

Add to wishlist

This product is usually dispatched within 2-4 weeks

Delivery and returns info
Flat rate of $10.00 for shipping anywhere in Australia

Description

In Philip K. Dick’s The Minority Report, ‘precogs’, who are imaginary individuals capable of seeing the future are relied upon to stop crime, with a consensus report synthesized from two of three precogs. When the protaganist is indicted for a future murder, he suspects a conspiracy and seeks out the “minority report,” detailing the suppressed testimony of the third precog. Science works a lot like this science fiction story. Contrary to the view that scientists in a field all share the same “paradigm,” as Thomas Kuhn famously argued, scientists support different, and competing, research programs. Statements of scientific consensus need to be actively synthesized from the work of different scientists. Not all scientific work will be equally credited by science as a whole. While this system works well enough for most purposes, it is possible for minority views to fail to get the hearing that they deserve.

This book analyzes the support that should be given to minority views, reconsidering classic debates in science and technology studies and examining numerous case studies.

1. Minority Report: Research Programmes and the Debate about Climate Change
2. Generating Challenges to Dominant Ideas: Lakatos and Feyerabend's Dialectical Alternative
3. Making Anomalies Work: Dialectical Engagement versus Anomaly-Mongering in Evolutionary Biology
4. Members Only: Wittgensteinian Sociology and the Debate about Carbohydrates and Fat
5. The Place of Science and the Turn to Material Practice: A Lab of One's Own for Patient Activists
6. Counterfactuals and Second-Guessing Scientists and Engineers: Green Chemistry, the Precautionary Principle, and Social Movements in the History of Science
7. Commodification and the Erosion of the Scientific Ethos
Bibliography
Index

Product details

Published	16 Oct 2020
Format	Hardback
Edition	1st
Extent	380
ISBN	9781786612373
Imprint	Rowman & Littlefield Publishers
Illustrations	1 b/w illustrations;3 tables;
Dimensions	227 x 160 mm
Series	Collective Studies in Knowledge and Society
Publisher	Bloomsbury Publishing

Author

William T. Lynch

The interdisciplinary field of science, technology, and society (STS) was launched in the 1980s to challenge perceived overreach of scientific authority. As STS scholars honed their critical tools, however, assaults on scientific authority gradually became associated with the same conservative, rapaciously capitalist interests the field of STS had first set out to critique. Championing scientific dissent, possibly undercutting scientists' expertise, and emphasizing contingencies in the scientific process became problematic for STS scholars to pursue. The subsequent reckoning has motivated Lynch to develop tools for determining when minority scientific positions should and should not be taken seriously. Lynch's argument follows Bruno Latour, whose Down to Earth (CH, May'19, 56-3759) attempted to put STS on a new footing. The result is a thorough and thoughtful overview of the past half-century of thinking on scientific consensus and dissent, articulated through cases ranging from dietary science to climate change. The book proposes useful conceptual tools to help sort the minority wheat from the minority chaff. Scholars in STS and adjacent fields will find this a rewarding and provocative read… Recommended. Graduate students and faculty.

Choice Reviews