Loewe provides an insightful analysis of a contest over control of land on his institution’s campus. Owned by the State of California, the land in question is considered common ‘green space’ for students and community members, as well as an iconic feature of the campus. More importantly, a number of Indigenous communities in southern California define the 22-acre expanse as sacred. Puvungna, as they know it, is a burial site and the birthplace of culture hero Chinigchinich. Several Native communities continue to conduct ceremonies there. The sanctity of the space was threatened during the early 1990s when the university moved to allow the commercial development of the site. Eight chapters divided into three parts effectively provide historical and cultural contexts for understanding Puvungna as a sacred site; detail the six-year political, legal, and academic struggle during the 1990s; and offer broader reflections on contests over sacred lands and how to marshal effective political action. Based primarily on archival sources and oral histories, this excellent and substantive work could not be timelier, given ongoing controversies over Native land and resource rights. It also broadens perspectives found in the literature on repatriation and sacred lands….

Summing Up: Highly recommended. General and academic collections.

Choice Reviews

Loewe’s narrative lands squarely at the intersection where academia meets activism. He adopts the even tone and temper of a patient and observant diarist examining the anatomy of a controversy by dutifully interrogating the biography of a sacred landscape. The book is appealing for its historical depth and breadth, and will also serve as a primer on working within and around grass-roots native groups and organizations. It offers not just hope, but practical, level-headed advice based on real-life experience.

Kurt W. Russo, Executive Director, Native American Land Conservancy

There are very few extended, well-documented case studies of the kind of conflict represented by the Puvungna case. Clear and understandably organized, this book will be especially relevant reading for CRM and EIA practitioners concerned with current issues in the management of historic places.

Thomas F. King, Owner, Thomas F. King PhD LLC

An ethnohistorical approach to a multi-faceted social problem… Loewe ably balances the expression of various subgroup interests, positions, and interpretations related to land use and development, and demonstrates the human complexities surrounding what appears to be a simple situation of a public agency deciding to develop a piece of land. However, the overall society’s hegemony fails to acknowledge pre-Columbian indigenous peoples’ ownership, use, and spiritual connection with land.

Donald D. Pepion, New Mexico State University