In a short review it is impossible to do justice to the breadth of intriguing material discussed by Irwin and the conclusions he draws about modern religious sensibilities. The major thing that can and must be said is that the book is a major scholarly achievement and one more very big nail in the coffin of the theory that modernity is synonymous with secularism and disenchantment. Irwin’s book will appeal to all readers interested in the way humans have answered the great existential questions about the purpose and meaning of human life and the pain and suffering that accompanies it.

Nova Religio: The Journal Of Alternative And Emergent Religions

Reincarnation in America by Lee Irwin is a work of vast scope, covering even more than its title would suggest about reincarnation theories and traditions. Here you will find much that was never before gathered into a single book, whose range extends from ancient Greek and Roman sources to Native American, medieval, and early modern traditions, right up to contemporary scientific research. A great accomplishment—highly recommended!

Arthur Versluis, author of American Gurus, American Gnosis

In his new book, Lee Irwin traces the idea of reincarnation from the ancient world to the modern North American scene through the prism of the category of esotericism, that is, all of those secret teachings or experiences that generally lie outside the mainstream of Western religious thought and so are often rejected as unorthodox, superstitious, heretical, magical, or, these days, “anecdotal.” The aesthetic and intellectual effect of the book is a profound double sense of just how widespread and common but also how diverse and complicated the different historical models of rebirth actually are. This is scholarship on religion in the classical sense: at once deeply historical and robustly comparative, and always pushing toward the philosophical, moral and cosmological implications of the comparative data.

Jeffrey J. Kripal, Rice University

Lee Irwin provides readers with a thorough survey of beliefs in reincarnation across cultures and throughout history, presented in a style that is both scholarly and personal at once. The book will be a valuable resource for students and non-academics who want to learn more about the history of reincarnation beliefs, how such beliefs have appeared in different religious and spiritual traditions, or who have an interest in the scientific attempts made to understand the nature of such experiences as past-life memories.

Christopher M. Moreman

[The] book is a historical overview of virtually every possible influence on contemporary American belief in reincarnation. This is the best part of this work, which displays the impressive erudition of its author, who seamlessly moves from Native American shamanism to transpersonal psychology. The twenty chapters in which the book is divided are a gold mine of information and bibliographic references for anyone wishing to delve into the theme of reincarnation.

Religious Studies Review