Skip to main content

Vienna Lectures on Legal Philosophy, Volume 4

Constitutional Disagreements

Vienna Lectures on Legal Philosophy, Volume 4 cover

Vienna Lectures on Legal Philosophy, Volume 4

Constitutional Disagreements

Quantity
Pre-order. Available 06 Aug 2026
$162.00 RRP $180.00 Website price saving $18.00 (10%)

Payment for this pre-order will be taken when the item becomes available

This product is usually dispatched within 2-4 weeks following the publication date

Description

In the fourth volume of the Vienna Lectures on Legal Philosophy, scholars in contemporary jurisprudence and constitutional theory discuss who gets to decide and who gets to act when constitutional law is silent or fundamentally controversial.

It is the very purpose of Constitutions to settle disagreements: to determine who gets to decide and who gets to act when it comes to the polity and its members.

But what if, instead of settling disagreements among those subjected to it, the Constitution itself, its end, its functions, its meaning, its existence, becomes the subject of disagreements? What if the Constitution raises issues it is unable to address from the very outset? Who gets to decide then and who gets to act?

In a time in which constitutional crises seem to be too ubiquitous to still count as exceptions, questions such as these are asked with ever-increasing urgency. The answers to these questions cannot be found in arguments based on contingent legal stipulations but have to reach beyond the vague and fleeting instructions of positive law.

Table of Contents

1. Why Constitutions? The Case for Robust Constitutionalism, Alon Harel (The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel)
2. When the Constitution is Like a House: On Metaphors in Legal Reasoning, Yaniv Roznai (Interdisciplinary Centre Herzliya, Israel)
3. The Constitution as an Obstacle: On Constitutional Disagreements as Constitutional Safeguards, Christoph Bezemek (University of Graz, Austria)
4. Deep Disagreements: Contradicting Constitutions of Reality, Sophie Loidolt (Technical University of Darmstadt, Germany)
5. Constitutional Disagreements or Institutional Failure? Legal Flexibility and Rigidity in Democratic Societies, Michaela Hailbronner (University of Münster, Germany)
6. Dworkin on Disagreement, Cormac Mac Amlaigh (University of Edinburgh, UK)
7. Kant's Principle of Right as a Principle of Collective Freedom, George Pavlakos (University of Glasgow, UK)
8. The Dethroned Forum of Principle: Re-drawing the Power/Knowledge Matrix in Constitutional Theory, Roni Mann (Barenboim-Said Akademie, Germany)
9. Enlightenment, Myth, and the Total Constitution, Martin Loughlin (LSE, UK)
10. The Total State and the Total Constitution, Anna-Bettina Kaiser (Humboldt University, Germany)
11. Procedural Legitimation and Substantive Legitimacy in the Current Crisis of Democracy, Stephan Kirste (University of Salzburg, Austria)
12. Hans Kelsen, Leo Strauss, and the Crisis of American Democracy, William Scheuerman (Indiana University, USA)
13. Judicial Dialogue and Constitutional Disagreements: Bridging the Gap, Koen Lenaerts (KU Leuven, Belgium)
14. Who Decides? Monstrous Government and the Dangers of Private Power, Adrian Vermeule (University of Harvard, USA)
15. Restoring Democracy Through International Law, Kim Lane Scheppele (Princeton University, USA)
16. The Linchpin of Constitutional Discipline: Militant Democracy and the Republican Split, Alexander Somek (University of Vienna, Austria)

Product details

Published 06 Aug 2026
Format Hardback
Edition 1st
Extent 288
ISBN 9781509983568
Imprint Hart Publishing
Dimensions 234 x 156 mm
Series Vienna Lectures on Legal Philosophy
Publisher Bloomsbury Publishing

About the contributors

Anthology Editor

Christoph Bezemek

Christoph Bezemek is Professor of Law at the Unive…

Anthology Editor

Michael Potacs

Michael Potacs is Professor of Law at the Instutut…

Anthology Editor

Alexander Somek

Alexander Somek is Professor of Legal Philosophy a…

Related Titles

Get 30% off in the May sale - for one week only

Environment: Staging