In Character in the American Experience: An Unruly People, Frohnen and McAllister plumb the American past to uncover the dispositions, habits, folkways, and institutions that have bound a people characterized by intense cultural, regional, and local differences. The burden of this remarkably readable and jargon free book is to disclose the unique ways such a diverse country have learned to cooperate and agree on matters of vital public interest and to disagree without rancor and division when consensus was unavoidable. For all those concerned about the forces dividing the country, and the means for containing those forces, this book is an essential must read.

Darren Staloff, City College of New York

In this bold and timely book, Frohnen and McAllister have revived the idea that the study of the American past can be a profoundly moral undertaking, offering us clues to sources of our current dilemmas, and gesturing toward the recovery of our troubled national soul. By emphasizing character, and its essential role in the life of a free people, the authors have advanced a very unfashionable position. But so much the worse for fashion, especially when it stands in the way of the truth. This book show by example how historians can help us recover what we are losing, before it is too late.

Wilfred McClay, Hillsdale College

Character in the American Experience is worth reading to reacquaint Americans with both the national and local stories we tell ourselves. In this age of media fragmentation and scholarly specialization, this book is a welcome antidote in narrating the story of our country from its founding to today. What we discover is that we always have been an unruly people, from the very beginning. It is a fact that gives us hope that our current disagreements and fights are not signs of our democracy’s weakness but its enduring strength.

Front Porch Republic

This book builds on David Hackett Fischer’s seminal history of the British folkways that underpin modern American culture, Albion’s Seed. These “deeper historical currents” take precedence over changing demographics and shifting political attitudes in determining a nation’s culture. The book shows how America’s original settlers had vastly more power than immigrants in shaping America, from its common English language to its British legal system and Protestant religion. Protestantism came in several flavors, so Americans valued tolerance as “a practical necessity rather than an imposed ideal.”….How do we recreate a functional country when ours is no longer bound by custom, language, or religion? The authors hope for a “self-respecting, honorable, and self-governing people” who can “begin anew.” Good luck, America.

Chronicles: A Magazine of American Culture