Recognizing Spinoza's philosophy as distinctively unique, Polka offers an original approach. . . . The central tenet of Polka's apprach is his provocative but at the same time polemically engaging proposition that Spinozacan only be adequately understoodif he is recognized as both resolutely modern and biblical at the same time. The merit of Polka's study lies in its highlighting of this structure of mutually illuminating satellite texts without stipulating a doctrinaire core. Rather, Polka's approach brings out the philosophically critical impetus of Spinoza's thought that resists doctrinaire reduction and grasps its subject matter by the particular method and type of argumentation it requires.

H-Net: Humanities and Social Science Reviews Online

Like his earlier Hermeneutics and Ontology, Brayton Polka's [Between Philosophy and Religion] is a work as eloquent as it is erudite. No reader could fail to learn from this monumental study a great deal about the relations between democratic freedom and eternal freedom, between consciousness and desire, and indeed what it is to be modern.

Kevin Hart, University of Notre Dame

Recognizing Spinoza's philosophy as distinctively unique, Polka offers an original approach. . . . The central tenet of Polka's apprach is his provocative but at the same time polemically engaging proposition that Spinozacan only be adequately understood if he is recognized as both resolutely modern and biblical at the same time. The merit of Polka's study lies in its highlighting of this structure of mutually illuminating satellite texts without stipulating a doctrinaire core. Rather, Polka's approach brings out the philosophically critical impetus of Spinoza's thought that resists doctrinaire reduction and grasps its subject matter by the particular method and type of argumentation it requires.

H-Net: Humanities and Social Science Reviews Online