This is the second book I have heavily underlined and thoroughly enjoyed by this author . . . The book would be a good central text or companion text for an upper-division undergraduate communication course, be it narrative theory, philosophy of communication, conflict, argumentation, or communication and society . . . . Anyone with a desire to understand why communication in not a panacea should read this book because it offers a clear understanding of why the cultural wars over topics like gay rights and abortion that occur in religious and secular narratives in public discourse will never satisfactorily resolve. By the end, I had a better understanding and was immediately able to communicate more productively when faced with fundamentalist expressions.

Communication Research Trends

Though he ranges widely across the theoretical landscape, John Sumser is lucid and engaging as he deftly pulls his thesis together under the concept of 'narrative.' By demonstrating how the 'culture war' is a conflict between religious and secular narratives that each make meaning in different ways, Sumser brings a fresh light to a subject often characterized by the heat of conflict. Religious and secular readers of this helpful book may still disagree on issues of public concern, but will perhaps see how current debates accomplish little more than 'talking past' one another. The alternative that Sumser proposes, to at least recognize the differing stories by which we and others make sense of our worlds, offers a basis for meaningful dialogue.

Mark Ward Sr., University of Houston–Victoria

John Sumser beautifully dissects the narratives and reasoning styles which undergird contemporary religious and secular thought. His deep analysis reveals the ways in which faith and reason utilize different kinds of language games. By clarifying how religious and secular apologists speak past one another, Sumser provides us with a new perspective on an age-old question: ‘what is really real?’ This book is essential reading for anyone interested in evaluating the popular polemics of Christian fundamentalism and the New Atheism.

Paul Froese, Baylor University and author of On Purpose: How We Create the Meaning of Life

A well-written and insightful explanation of how Christian fundamentalist and New Atheism beliefs are communicated through polarizing narratives which buttress the religious and secular divisions that afflict contemporary American society.

Barry A. Kosmin, Trinity College, Hartford, Conneticut