Lyons, a criminal defense attorney and a death penalty expert, offers an interesting premise to fix the legal system in the US—a system in which “the need for criminal justice reform is salient and apparent.”…. Using cases that often had tragic outcomes, Lyons demonstrates how a defender general could step in and make sure that those in the criminal justice system are treated fairly. The office would be responsible for funding, advocacy, and policy; an outline is provided to implement these three areas. Lyons believes a defender general would be able to create standards for defending attorneys and consequences for less-than-honorable actions toward clients. With this idea, Lyons has started the conversation to repair a broken system of justice. This conversation needs to continue. Recommended. Undergraduates through faculty and practitioners.

Choice Reviews

In Fixing Legal Injustice in America, Andrea Lyon, a veteran criminal defense attorney, urges that we need to create an Office of the Defender General of the Unite States – a counterbalance to the Office of the Attorney General. The book is compelling and enlightening. Part legal history lesson, part war stories, and part a call to action, Lyon drives home the need for a federal position to advocate for criminal defendants and their attorneys.

The Champion, NACDL

Providing legal assistance to the indigent accused of crimes has been devalued, diminished and overlooked for centuries. Andrea Lyon makes a compelling argument that the status and role of the defender must change if our system is to become more reliable, fair and just.

Bryan Stevenson, director of the Equal Justice Initiative in Alabama and bestselling author of Just Mercy

Andrea Lyon, a gifted lawyer, also proves to be a wonderful writer. Through the heart-rending stories of some of her clients, she proves her case beyond any doubt: The famously unequal treatment of the poor in US courts is due most fundamentally to the dramatic disparities in public resources afforded to prosecution and defense. Most important, Andrea Lyon tells us how to fix that problem.

Scott Turow, New York Times best-selling author, Presumed Innocent

Fixing Legal Injustice in America offers a heartfelt, poignant perspective on why the United States needs a Defender General, who will fight for the poor and oppressed. A Defender General will create a seat at the table where one simply has not existed before, and the Defender General will be able to create change. We all know lots of good people and organizations are working tirelessly to end mass incarceration and reform the criminal justice system. The Defender General will help to strengthen these individual, grassroots, and often disparate efforts by addressing policy, advocacy, and funding at the same level as the Attorney General of the United States. As Andrea Lyon so eloquently tells the reader through her stories and examples, the United States needs a Defender General. We need a seat at the table.

Sister Helen Prejean, Author of "Dead Man Walking"

One of our country’s most skilled public defenders, Andrea D. Lyon, brings us heartbreaking insights from the trenches to make a passionate case for the creation of a national Defender General—someone endowed with a powerful voice to protect the rights of the accused, correct wrongful convictions, and fight racism and other entrenched systemic problems. This is an engaging, thought-provoking, and persuasive book that will speak to everyone interested in fixing our broken criminal legal system.

Carol S. Steiker, Harvard Law School